HATCH FLIP-FLOP OF THE WEEK: VOLUME 1, ISSUE 2
Hatch Vows To Abide By DFL Endorsement In 1990
Mitch Pearlstein and Peter Bell: Eibensteiner was the victim in this sorry case
Permit us to add a coda to the recent acquittal of former Minnesota Republican Party Chairman Ron Eibensteiner on charges he orchestrated an illegal campaign contribution in 2002. ("Coda" is a fancy word for, "We're grateful our longtime friend and colleague was acquitted on every single count against him, though we remain steamed that he and his family had to fend off such a baseless and unfair prosecution to begin with.")
Did this sorry episode reinforce the fact that state and federal campaign finance laws rival state and federal tax codes for the confusion they cause and the lack of respect they engender? Obviously. Yet complexity was never a germane point in this case, as Ron was never confused about the law's prohibitions and he never did anything wrong.
Oh, we need to amend that. He did, in fact, sign a form letter without reading it first. Given that the two of us have signed thousands of form letters in our lives, we trust it's not unreasonable to assume that maybe, just maybe we've affixed our names to pieces of paper we should have crumpled and tossed instead. There for the grace of good staff work -- and the fact that no one ever purloined any of our form letters from someone else's home -- we've been spared. Ron, unfortunately, was not nearly as lucky.
This last point raises profound questions about prosecutorial overreach. We're both big on law and order. But it's profoundly useful every once in a while to grasp the extraordinary power of county attorneys and other prosecutors -- not only to bring down outlaws -- but also to bring low and hurt perfectly innocent people.
Put aside the emotional roller coaster to which Ron and his family were recklessly subjected, and just follow the real money crime at issue: How much do you think it cost Ron to defend himself against charges that never should have been brought in the first place?
A final and fair question for us would be: Is this letter spurred in any way by the fact that Ron Eibensteiner is a very good friend, and we're not the least bit happy whenever years of generosity and civic-mindedness by very good friends are overshadowed for no just purpose?
Beyond a shadow of a doubt, we're guilty. Source: Star Tribune, November 27, 2005
|W|P|113311924159697535|W|P|OP-ED ON THE CASE AGAINST EIBENSTEINER|W|P|minnesotademocratsexposed@hotmail.comThe eloquent wordsmith blogger known as First Ringer has a post about my legal troubles. This guy is really good.
|W|P|113283845433606779|W|P|UPDATE: A MESSAGE FROM MDE: I NEED YOUR HELP #21|W|P|minnesotademocratsexposed@hotmail.comAlmost on the Range has posted on my legal troubles.
I've spent my life working for a safe, secure Minnesota."
Thanks to Entenza's campaign, the Minnesotans who signed up to receive updates about the campaign via their email addresses should be concerned their privacy is no longer private.
Nice work, Minnesota's Watchdog!
|W|P|113269053491587048|W|P|THANKS TO ENTENZA, EMAIL ADDRESSES NO LONGER PRIVATE|W|P|minnesotademocratsexposed@hotmail.com
I have never been more proud of House Speaker Steve Sviggum. This is the exact type of speech Republicans need to give to Minnesotans.
##
Sviggum speaks to Beltrami Country Republicans
Sviggum was the keynote speaker Tuesday night at a Beltrami County Republican fund-raiser at Bemidji State University's David Park House, where about 35 people heard stump speeches from six candidates for various offices.
Among them, former Rep. Doug Lindgren, R-Bagley, said he would try to recapture the seat he lost in 2004 to Brita Sailer, DFL-Park Rapids. And Bemidji's Ridgewood Baptist Church Rev. David Myers announced his campaign against Rep. Frank Moe, DFL-Bemidji.
Also, Sen. Carrie Ruud, R-Breezy Point, signaled a re-election campaign in 2006 by asking to return her to St. Paul for a shot at capturing the majority in the Senate from the Democrats.
"We are so close," she said. "The way the (Republicans) take the majority is for me to keep this seat, and … the DFL does not like me representing Bemidji.
Sviggum, R-Kenyon, has his eyes set on recapturing the House 2B seat, where Sailer beat Lindgren, and House 4A, where Moe beat three-term incumbent Rep. Doug Fuller, R-Bemidji, who isn't seeking a rematch in 2006.
"The House needs two more members from northern Minnesota on the majority side of the aisle," Sviggum said.
He lumped Moe and Sailer with their caucus leader, Minority Leader Matt Entenza, DFL-St. Paul, as "three peas in a pod and that is not Bemidji. … We exchanged the two Dougs (Fuller and Lindgren) for two liberal, leftist extremists, and that’s not Bemidji."
He described Entenza and Twin Cities liberals as "pro-abortion, pro-gun control, pro-gay marriage, big spending, big taxing," adding that "Sailer and Moe, with a smile on their face, vote with them 90 percent of the time. You give your vote away to the liberals in Minneapolis and St. Paul."
Sviggum said if he told Bemidjians that the urban liberals from the Twin Cities were running Bemidji, "Paul Bunyan would be blushing, and Babe the Blue Ox would turn pink. And that’s what's taking place."
He asked local Republicans if they remembered what they learned in kindergarten and Sunday school: "Share what you have, play fair, clean up your own mess, put things back where you find them, don't take things that aren't yours, treat people the way you want to be treated … it's a pretty good philosophy of life and it's a pretty good Republican philosophy."
It means balance both in life and in government, he said.
"You cannot and you should not govern from the extreme, radical left," Sviggum said, adding that it should also apply to the extreme radical right. "There’s got to be some room for compromise and cooperation. The radical left have forgotten hard work, individual responsibility, risk, reward, the market, the American dream, the American experiment.
"They've forgotten it, they're whacko, they're left and they're gone,” Sviggum said. “You can't govern from there."
He called the DFL strategy "cynical," as the DFL Senate stymied budget efforts by confronting Republicans in 2004 and 2005 because they didn’t face an election.
The Bemidji area missed $33 million in bonding projects in 2004 because the Senate didn't pass a bonding bill, while House Republicans faced re-election that fall, he said. And this year, DFLers forced a special session and government shutdown just to embarrass GOP Gov. Tim Pawlenty, he said.
"From the beginning, it was going to be a special session," Sviggum said. "Their strategy was to embarrass the governor, to someway reduce the popularity that he had."
In the upcoming session, the cornerstones of Republican philosophy have to be faith, family, freedom and work. He labeled debate on a constitutional amendment ballot question that gay marriages be banned in Minnesota as "very, very important."
That also appears to be one of the key campaign issues for Myers, who hopes to unseat Moe next year.
"Frank Moe has done a good job representing his constituents," Myers said. "But he's dangerous if we leave him there."
Important to Myers is the Marriage and Family Act, "which defines marriage as one man and one woman. If you send me to St. Paul, I will work very hard … to try to bring that before the voters."
Moe will not support the act because state law already bars it, Myers said. "He's not going to come out and say that he's for gay rights, because Frank is a middle-of-the-road kind of guy. But I'm not a middle-of-the-road kind of guy … it was the law of the land in Massachusetts
it's the law of the land until the Legislature decides it's not."
It needs to be part of the State Constitution where lawmakers can’t tamper with it, he said.
"We need to try to stop abortion wherever we can," he added. "I will work hard to try to stem the tide. Whenever I get the opportunity to push it back, I’ll do that."
Myers has never run for public office, but said he's worked on several campaigns. He retired four years ago from the U.S. Navy, where he had a 22-year career as a diver.
Lindgren said he enjoyed his only two-year term in the Legislature, and wants to return. His family runs a Bagley service station while he teaches auto mechanics at Northwest Technical Colleg
"I've got to do it," he said. "Once you get this in your blood, you can't get it out. … I loved my two years being a representative, and I’m going to do it again."
Ruud plans to seek a second, four-year term. Now in the Senate minority, she said she felt hamstrung and that the GOP needs to wrest control of the chamber.
"It was very clear from Day 1 that we were headed toward shutdown," she said of the past session. "There was never an agenda to get anything done."
Even the night of the shutdown, an agreement was close, but Senate Majority Leader Dean Johnson, DFL-Willmar, adjourned the body, she said. "When you hear the governor shut down the state of Minnesota, it's not true. Sen. Dean Johnson shut down the state of Minnesota.
"Those of us who believe in government and believe we are there to do what’s best for the state of Minnesota, really couldn't believe that politics could be more important than policy and the good of the state," Ruud said. It's difficult for a minority member to get bills passed, Ruud said, adding that many bills she wanted passed had to be put through DFL authors in order to pass.
"I passed 70 percent of the bills I introduced last year, but the sad thing is most of them don't have my name on them anymore because I'm in the minority," she said.
"It's not all about who gets credit, but I would love for my bills to have my name on them, and the only way we're going to do that is for the (Republicans) to take the majority,” Ruud said.
She urged those at the fund-raiser for their help, especially in letting her know of events to attend locally, and alluded that she has been snubbed from some events.
"If you seen an event, like yesterday's (Monday's), that I should be invited to, or that I should attend, I need you to tell me,” she said."It's obvious I'm not going to find out about those events."
Let her know because she’ll be there, Ruud said. "I've been in Bemidji three, four times a week
I've been here, I've represented this city. … I think I've proven to you I can work hard."
Ruud referred to a meeting Monday between a delegation of Russian local government officials and with Moe, Sailer and Sen. Rod Skoe, DFL-Clearbrook, at which the visitors learned about state government and politics.
Kath Molitor, Beltrami County Republican Chairwoman, said that Ruud was not invited, even though she was in Bemidji on Monday.
"We need our senator in Bemidji, not someone else's senator," Molitor said. "Why wasn't Carrie invited to talk politics with the Russians? This has got to stop."
Sviggum said that he and Pawlenty plan to spend a day in Bemidji doing a variety of activities on Jan. 6. Source: Bemidji Pioneer, November 22, 2005
"But he said those efforts were greatly hampered by a Minnesota political culture that swung sharply negative during his time in St. Paul.
'It's strategic game-playing as opposed to policy discussion,' he said. When both sides concentrate on personal attacks, he added, 'the only thing the public understands is that we're all bad people.'" Source: Star Tribune, November 21, 2005
|W|P|113262620256135657|W|P|NO COMPROMISING FOR HOTTINGER|W|P|minnesotademocratsexposed@hotmail.comHottinger says he's announcing his decision now, so others interested in running have time to make plans.
Hottinger is a St. Peter lawyer who was first elected in 1990. He served as Senate majority leader in 2003.
While he's enjoyed his time in the Legislature, Hottinger says the divisiveness of recent sessions has made the Legislature a less happy place.
As he put it, "We have to find ways to talk to each other.'' Source: Associated Press, November 21, 2005
|W|P|113260347566712784|W|P|HOTTINGER WILL NOT SEEK RE-ELECTION|W|P|minnesotademocratsexposed@hotmail.comThis is from the Associated Press:
3 p.m. State Senator John Hottinger, DFL-St. Peter, will make an announcement regarding his political future.
Location: State Capitol, Room 125, St. Paul
Contacts: Sen. Hottinger's office, (651) 296-6153
|W|P|113260328929559805|W|P|IS HOTTINGER RESIGNING?|W|P|minnesotademocratsexposed@hotmail.comFundraiser note raised a ruckus
Ron Jerich, a Minnesota lobbyist with DFL ties, was at his home in Mendota Heights in
October 2002 as the election season was reaching fever pitch. Jerich was waiting to go door to door for DFL candidates with 20 volunteers. He had no idea that he was about to become a pawn in what he considers an attempt by Minnesota's top legal officer to target political opponents.
Attorney General Mike Hatch, whom Jerich describes as a longtime friend, was among the door-knockers gathering at Jerich's home. Jerich says he showed Hatch a form letter from Ron Eibensteiner, then chair of the Minnesota Republican Party.
The letter thanked Jerich for a donation that one of his corporate clients had made to a national Republican committee.
"Mike's eyes lit up," Jerich says. "I couldn't understand his interest. He knew I raised money for both political parties, and Eibensteiner's letter was a simple thank you." Jerich thought nothing more about the letter until later that evening, when he searched all over but couldn't find it. It wasn't until months later, Jerich says, when Hatch publicly admitted taking the letter, that "it dawned on me that Mike had taken the letter when I wasn't looking."
Last week, Hatch spokeswoman Leslie Sandberg said Jerich gave the letter to Hatch.
Eibensteiner is convinced that Hatch saw the letter as political gold, and waited for an opportunity to use it to maximum advantage.
About five months later, Hatch's office provided the letter to the St. Paul Pioneer Press, according to Hatch's own testimony. It served as the basis for a story suggesting that Eibensteiner might have broken campaign finance laws and that the administration of Tim Pawlenty -- by then the new governor (and Hatch's political rival) -- may have entered into a sweetheart deal in settling charges against Jerich's corporate client, a Florida insurance company.
At a subsequent state Senate committee hearing in March 2003, Hatch testified that he had shown the letter to state Commerce Commissioner Glenn Wilson and urged him to avoid such a settlement, though Wilson vigorously denied this. A legislative auditor's probe in May found no evidence of wrongdoing by the Pawlenty administration, though it did criticize aspects of the settlement. Meanwhile, the report pronounced some of Hatch's behavior in connection with the case "troubling."
Some months after this, Jerich's purloined letter surfaced again, becoming the principal evidence in a criminal case against Eibensteiner.
The case featured many curious elements. Its venue was Mower County, something of a DFL stronghold along the Iowa border. "Mower County was targeted as the venue of the complaint," says Bill Mauzy, Eibensteiner's attorney, "and the presentation to the grand jury was results-oriented for an indictment against the insurance company and the Republican Eibensteiner."
Hatch was a star witness against Eibensteiner, who describes the attorney general as "consumed with rage and vindictiveness on the stand."
The jury took three hours last week to reach a verdict of not guilty.
"The story here," Mauzy says, "is the abuse of office of the attorney general to satisfy his own ambitions and go after his political enemies."
Sandberg, Hatch's spokeswoman, declined to comment on the attorney general's role in the case.
Mauzy's is a serious charge, but Hatch has for years been making serious charges in this matter that have not been found to have merit.
"Ron Eibensteiner did nothing wrong," Jerich says. "Now he's faced with trying to salvage his good name. I want my letter back."
Eibensteiner sees things a little differently. "It wasn't my reputation that was lost at that trial," he says. "It was Mike Hatch's." Source: Star Tribune, November 21, 2005
|W|P|113259414106406751|W|P|MIKE HATCH IS A THIEF|W|P|minnesotademocratsexposed@hotmail.comI just received this email from a dedicated reader of Minnesota Democrats Exposed.
##
From: XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX Sent: Friday, November 18, 2005 7:04 PM To: minnesotademocratsexposed@hotmail.com Subject: FW: Hopkins Schools S.O.D. MDE, I received this email. It has big implications for SD43 DFL Candidate Terri Bonoff, who has been touting her impact on Hopkins Education [.]
The Superintendent of the district (Michael Kremer) who had the message sent out on his behalf seconded Terri's nomination at the SD43 DFL BPOU convention and her campaign manager is the treasuer of the board! ****** Below is an email I just received stating that Hopkins Schools were operating at Statutory Operating Deficit (SOD) for 2004-2005. This is huge. Explains why all three School Board incumbents did not run this year. It's also potentially huge considering Terri Bonoff and Barb Klass have been Co-Chairs of the LAC over the past five years or so. Furthermore, Barb Klass has also been a current school board member (has been for many years) and as you also know, Barb Klass is also Terri's campaign chair. ----- Original Message ----- From: To: LAC Steering Comm Group Sent: Friday, November 18, 2005 07:02 Subject: 2004-05 Audit Dear Members of the LAC Steering Committee (this message is from Superintendent Michael Kremer), Recently, we learned that Hopkins School District 270 is in statutory operating debt (SOD), which is based on the preliminary findings of the fiscal year 2005 (2004-05 school year) audit. This audit is still being completed and will be presented to the Hopkins School Board, Thursday, Dec. 15. We discussed this situation with the School Board publicly, Thursday, Nov. 17, and wanted to share it will all of you as soon as possible also. The preliminary audit findings indicate that the District ended fiscal year 2005 with a negative unreserved general fund balance of -$4,329,464, which is a –5.4 percent of operating expenses. Under Minnesota law, a school district enters statutory operating debt when it spends in excess of a –2.5 percent unreserved general fund balance. At no time is statutory operating debt acceptable. As your superintendent, I accept full responsibility for this situation, and want to assure you that over the next weeks we will be aggressively working to develop a plan to correct it. As you know, the Hopkins School District has had six consecutive years of difficult budget decisions, resulting in more than $18.2 million worth of reductions. The Citizens Financial Advisory Committee (CFAC) and School Board have recommended sitting on the edge of statutory debt since 1999. For the 2004-05 school year, the District intentionally adopted an unbalanced budget fully expecting to end the fiscal year with a negative fund balance. This was done to maintain the District's educational program as much as possible in the wake of no additional funding from the state, and being prevented from seeking additional operating levy authority from residents. There is risk involved with having no fund balance, but the District intentionally chose to spend money on programs and services for kids. However, that negative fund balance slipped further than expected, and now the situation needs to be corrected. Due to multiple employee turnover in the District's Business Office, the increasing negative fund balance was not detected until this year’s audit of the 2004–05 budget. Had we known about it earlier, we would have done something about it earlier. Some of the corrective work has already started with a series of recommendations from the District's Citizens Financial Advisory Committee. This volunteer group annually reviews the District's financial picture, and recommends expense limits to the Hopkins School Board. This year's recommendations include: * Suspending the School Board's policy of maintaining an unreserved general fund balance of between 3 percent and 5 percent of operating expenditures in order to maintain the quality of the District's programs and services, and establishing a goal to work within current policy parameters within five years. * Being clear of statutory operating debt status within three years. * Completing annual audits by October 1st of each year. * Creating and implementing an improved financial monitoring system, allowing budget managers to review revenue and expenditure data in a just-in-time manner. This includes generating reports for all budget managers on a monthly basis, and negotiating appropriate budget adjustments. * Providing comprehensive fund balance reports to the Board on a monthly basis, and updating the Citizens Financial Advisory Committee on a quarterly basis. * Suspending the Program-Based Budgeting system for fiscal year 2007 (covering the 2006-07 school year), and directing the superintendent to work with staff to prepare a draft of a budget to deliver to the full Board in late December, and to share with the community for review and comment thereafter. * Restructuring the Business Office to meet current District needs. * Continuing to seek alternative non-traditional revenue flows, creating new positive revenue streams into the District, not reducing expenditures. CFAC members have already looked at multi-year budget simulations designed to gradually bring the District out of SOD in three years. The District's plan to remove it from SOD must be submitted to the Minnesota Department of Education for approval before Jan. 31, 2006. After Thanksgiving, I will begin developing a draft 2006-07 budget with the District's budget managers. This draft budget will be presented to the School Board on Dec. 15. It then will be presented to District staff, parents, and other community members in a series of meetings to be conducted during January. Information about this budget draft will be available on the District's Web site, and in a news release sent to local media. The District also will establish a budget comment voicemail line and email address that people can use to provide their feedback as well. Throughout the budget considerations and decision-making, the District will strive to maintain its educational programs and services. Our top priority will be to minimize the impact of any additional budget adjustments on classrooms and our education programs. We remain focused on delivering the best, top quality, education program. This is our commitment to our students and their parents, our staff, and our community. If you have any questions, please contact your building principal. I will be doing everything humanly possible to keep principals up-to-date with the best information available. Please remember, that the budget profile aligned with SOD is 2004-05. We have been blessed with good news since that time such as a successful referendum, new state aid, and Q-Comp, and our budget picture heading toward 2006-07 has improved considerably. So please don’t hesitate to ask questions, and know that we will provide you with updated information when it becomes available. Thank you. ******
|W|P|113237038356925129|W|P|BONOFF'S EDUCATION RECORD QUESTIONED|W|P|minnesotademocratsexposed@hotmail.comI received this first-hand account of a converstion Mike Hatch had with two reporters last week in Rochester. The person who sent me this information witness the conversation and I consider this sorce "unimpeachable." ##
Mike Hatch had just testified and he then walks outside the courtroom into the courthouse sitting area and is immediately approached by two men. The two men identify themselves as "Channel 6 reporters." The following is the conversation reconstructed, to the best of my recollection. The two reporters will be reported as one individual.
Mike Hatch: "It would really be inappropriate for me to comment on the case at all - remember all the trouble we got into over [inaudible]. I can tell you this - everyone thinks this is all about me running for governor but it's not."
Reporters: "Can you say anything, how was it in there? What's the feel?"
Mike Hatch: "I think the jury's taken aback at the amount of money that the Republicans sent to Minnesota and to Pawlenty - I mean, it's a staggering amount of money. The defense was standoffish, I think they're going to have a hard time."
The reporters asked one or two further questions concerning courtroom dynamics.
Mike Hatch: "You know, and I was just talking about this in the office the other day, no one in the press had made the Austin/Austin connection. You know, Austin Texas and Austin Minnesota. It's the same program of Republicans sending money, and I think that people would be interested in knowing that and reading about the Austin/Austin connection."
Then he paced the floor for about 15 minutes until a young woman came out of the courtroom, and he left with her.
##
Notice how quickly Hatch went from saying he shouldn't comment to then commenting. Hatch is unbelievable.